With housing prices still rising, albeit more slowly, inquiring minds might be wondering about “Real” interest rates and the “Real” CPI?
I believe the CPI is hugely distorted, but not for the same reasons as everyone else. Home prices used to be in the CPI but the BLS now uses OER (Owners’ Equivalent Rent). OER is a measure of actual rental prices as well as fiction.
The BLS determines OER from a measure of rental prices and also by asking the question “If someone were to rent your home today, how much do you think it would rent for monthly, unfurnished and without utilities?”
If you find that preposterous, You are not the only one. Regardless, rental prices are simply not a valid measure of home prices.
OER Weighting in CPI
OER has the single largest weight of any component in the CPI, at 23.957%.
Let’s play “What If?” Specifically, “What if the BLS used actual home prices instead of OER in calculating the CPI?”
Periodically, Black Knight Financial Services provides the actual data behind their HPI (Home Price Index), a measure of actual prices.
We can use that data to see what the CPI would look like if we put actual home prices in the CPI instead of OER.
I call this the “HPI-CPI”.
I passed on an Excel spreadsheet of the Black Knight HPI aggregate housing prices to Doug Short at Advisor Perspectives and we produced the charts below.
- Click on any chart to see a sharper image
- Data as of June 2014
- Annotations in purple by me
Let’s start with a look at the rate of increase in home prices vs. the rate of increases in OER.
Comparative Growth in HPI vs. OER
From 1994 until 1999 there was little difference in the rate of change of rent vs. housing prices. That changed in 2000 with the dot.com crash and accelerated when Greenspan started cutting rates.
The bubble is clearly visible but neither the Greenspan nor the Bernanke Fed spotted it. The Fed was more concerned with rents as a measure of inflation rather than speculative housing prices.
Two Inflation Indexes Year-over-Year
The above chart shows the effect when housing prices replace OER in the CPI. In mid-2004, the CPI was 3.27%, the HPI-CPI was 5.93% and the Fed Funds Rate was a mere 1%. By my preferred measure of price inflation, real interest rates were -4.93%. Speculation in the housing bubble was rampant.
In mid-2008 when everyone was concerned about “inflation” because oil prices had soared over $140, I suggested record low interest rates across the entire yield curve. At that time the CPI was close to 6% but the HPI-CPI was close to 0% (and plunging fast).
As measured by HPI-CPI real interest rates were positive from mid-2006 all the way to 2010, even when the Fed Funds rate crashed to .25%. That shows the power of the housing crash and how badly the Fed misplayed the housing bubble.
Real rates went positive again in mid-2010 until early 2011.
CPI and HPI-CPI Variance From Fed Funds Rate
The above chart shows two measures of “Real” interest rates. The Blue line is the Fed Funds Rate minus the CPI. The Red line is the Fed Funds Rate minus the HPI-CPI.
Both measures show how the Fed has pushed real rates into negative territory.
However, the rate of growth in home prices is slowing. If home prices actually start to decline, which I believe likely, HPI-CPI will show outright deflation.
And even with the Fed Funds rate at 0.25%, real rates will again be positive as measured by HPI-CPI, but perhaps not by the Fed who uses the CPI as its measure of price inflation.
Mike “Mish” Shedlock