On 24 February 2016, Hungary’s prime minister Viktor Orbán announced his government will hold a referendum on whether to accept the European Union’s proposed mandatory quotas for relocating migrants.
The referendum was deemed valid by the Hungarian constitutional court, and a vote is scheduled on October 2.
Ahead of the vote, Orbán ramped up rhetoric to the point of calling for a round-up of migrants and exportation to Africa.
Please consider Viktor Orban Calls for ‘Round-Up’ of Migrants in EU
“Those who came illegally must be rounded up and shipped out,” Mr Orban said in an interview released on Thursday by news website Origo.hu. He suggested an estimated 1.5m refugees and migrants who arrived on the continent last year should be sent to “an island or somewhere in north Africa” where European forces would enforce order. “That will solve all the problems,” he said.
“It’s the only solution that will work for everyone; for those of us who are not yet in trouble, because we protected ourselves. And also for countries like Germany, who are already in trouble,” he said. “The answer is to take [migrants] out of the union.”
Hungary sealed its border with Serbia last September, choking off the main route of migration into the EU via the western Balkans and diverting the flow westwards through Slovenia and Croatia. Other EU countries have since followed suit, although a German-sponsored EU deal with Turkey to reduce the influx of migrants has led to a drop in arrivals.
Mr Orban also took aim at Angela Merkel’s mea culpa this week, in which the German chancellor expressed regret that she could not “turn back the clock” to improve the country’s preparedness before she in effect welcomed in hundreds of thousands of migrants last year.
While her comments have been welcomed by some critics in Germany, the Hungarian premier suggested there was little substance behind them.
“What can I say about the German politicians and their policies?” he said. “I also would like to turn back the clock — what a great idea. But the problem is that it’s not possible.”
Merkel’s Alleged Mea Culpa
After a third place finish to AfD in her own state in recent German elections, then another big drubbing but a second place finish in Berlin, Merkel supposedly issued a Mea Culpa Aimed at Wooing Back Voters.
This was followed up with a message She Would Turn Back the Clock on Refugee Policy.
The “Mea Culpa” and the “turn back the clock” ideas are a complete crock of bullsheet. Pay attention to the exact phrasing:
“If I could, I would rewind time by many, many years so that I could better prepare myself and the whole government and all those in positions of responsibility for the situation that caught us unprepared in the late summer of 2015,” Ms Merkel said.
The chancellor also distanced herself from her phrase — “Wir schaffen das — we can do it” — which captured Germans’ belief last summer in their capacity to integrate the newly arrived refugees. She said it had become “a simple slogan, almost an empty formula” that underestimated the scale of the integration challenge.
The admission was aimed at winning back voters who have flocked to the rightwing, populist Alternative for Germany party, which has made big inroads this year by criticising Ms Merkel’s open-door approach to refugees. She was also responding to the growing ranks of conservative critics in her ruling CDU/CSU bloc, who have urged her to complement recent moves to tighten refugee policy with a more self-critical tone.
“The government has been on the right track with its policies for some time now. But our communication must be better,” said one CDU MP. “The chancellor seems now to have accepted this.”
Disingenuous Blather
What a joke. In Merkel’s Time Machine, she did not seek to undo her foolish decision to welcome refugees with open arms. Rather, she wanted go back further, “many years”, to be precise, to prepare for migration onslaught.
Her highness has not figured out that no amount of preparation could ever work!
Even if she was brilliant enough to be prepared, the other countries on the route would not have been. And of course Germany could never have prepared in the first place.
Why?
Because there is an endless demand for free handouts. Had Germany prepared for 1 million refugees, 5 million would have arrived.
Germany on Right Track Now?
Anyone placated by Merkel’s disingenuous “mea culpa” is a fool.
Her CDU party says “The government has been on the right track with its policies for some time now. But our communication must be better.”
That’s a crock of BS as well.
For starters, the flood of migrants dramatically slowed the moment Hungary and the Balkan states sealed there borders. Merkel takes credit for something Orbán accomplished.
Secondly, if the EU approves Turkey’s demand for visa-free access for 80 million Turks, another flood of migrants will be coming right up.
That said, Orbán is more than a bit off base. You can’t just take millions of migrants and dump them in Africa.
Related Articles
- September 19: Email From Germany: Reader Comments on CDU’s “Worst” Ever” Result in Berlin
- September 18: Merkel Suffers Setback in Berlin, CDU May Be Ousted from Coalition with SPD
- September 5: Merkel’s Coalition Suffers Dramatic Setback at Hands of AfD in Regional Elections
- March 13: Merkel’s Coalition Suffers Dramatic Setback at Hands of AfD in Regional Elections
Mike “Mish” Shedlock
The EU is disintegrating right before our eyes. For anyone paying attention, this is one of those moments in history to tell the grandkids about.
“That said, Orbán is more than a bit off base. You can’t just take millions of migrants and dump them in Africa.”
Why?
Sure you can. Its quite simple– offer them $3500, offer Kenya, Tanzania, Morocco, Jordan or whatever country agrees to accept them another $3500/head, and for four years offer them $500/mo in their new country. Oh yes– tell them they’re getting no benefits in Bulgaria. Money greases the skids quite nicely. It would be a very nice financial shot in the arm for the nations that agree to take them in. SuperMario can just hit the big “Print” button and solve this one tomorrow morning.
” You can’t just take millions of migrants and dump them in Africa.”
Well, not unless they came from Africa. Just send them back to wherever they came from. Duh!
You might think “leaders” like Merkel would be on a learning curve and get smarter as they go along. Obviously some people like Fuhrer Merkel are stuck in their ways. I can hardly wait for the present idiocracy to blow up.
They don’t have to transport any of them… it’s too expensive and why throw good money after bad? Just announce a Soylant Green project, display the menu and they will claw their way back all by themselves.
Didn’t Abe Lincoln have a similar wish and plan for the slaves?
Oh, I hope he sends the gypsies with ’em.
Orban wants to get rid of migrants. Merkel wants to integrate migrants. I say Orban should ship his 1.5 mil surplus over to Germany.
Julia that’s a great idea; I wish I had thought of it.
Essentially, Hungary is already committing treason and mutiny against the EU/Merkel over immigration. But there are no Soviet tanks to roll in, and the treason and mutiny will only get stronger over time. No doubt leading Hungary back to self-rule once again. In effect, Hungary is entering the time machine and traveling back to a time of self-rule devoid of Merkel.
If the EU lacks the army and will to bomb a dissident Hungary into submission the way Clinton/NATO bombed Serbia into submission, then the EU Empire gets closer to dissolution. Everyone expected Greece to be first out, and the UK surprised by making the first exit. Hungary seems poised to be second to exit (or perhaps expelled), as their actions must seem intolerable to Merkel and the Brussels nannycrats.
joelg5, You’re right there
you cant say that the EU already has a strange recent history of going about “building” itself up (with regards to former Yugoslavia (mid 1990s onward)
my argument at the time was: if it aint broken it, then why fix it?
EU answer: it aint broken, but we’re still going to fix it
(by smashing it to pieces first, and then rebuilding it in our own peculiar way)
Dear Mish
Maybe Mr. Orban has in mind an arrangement similar to the one between Australia and Papua. Such arrangement has cut the influx of illegal migrants to Australia to negligible numbers.
Regards
Alessandro
The real irony is that many of these refugees are from Syria, Libya, and Iraq — countries wrecked by US policies that Merkel supported.
zucco, it is no irony, it is a sad reality.
The apparent strategy: promote any justification for pre-emptive attacks, form a coalition of nations, and war with impunity is acceptable in foreign lands.
However, the humanitarian spin loses its effectiveness when demands surface to return refugees to their war torn homelands for a 2nd chance at being killed.
Why not Madagascar (h/t Hitler)?
At the moment there are about 580000 asylum seekers that has been refused in Germany running rampant. No-one knows who they are since 80% of them have had no papers on them and in some cases the application has been done just filling the paperwork – no interview or checks of identity!
Let me repeat this: Somewhere in Germany is over half a million people that we do not know who they are or what they are up to.
As far as I am concerned, Merkel can go to hell with her lies! She is not regretting anything. She makes only a point that we should do more. I have news for her, most Europeans are fed up with this nonsense and EU is on a brink of civil unrest.
What’s wrong with the “send them to Africa” ?
Unwelcome immigrants should be expelled. To whatever country accepts them. Wether their country, Germany or even Venezuela is Maduro accepts a “cash for refugees” program
Australia does it, and other countries can do it too.
Australia has a very straight enforcement of its borders, I don’t see why European countries could not do the same.
How ’bout a Trump-Orban or even a Orban-Trump ticket for Nov 08? Drop Pence. Now that’s a ticket I could really get behind.
And who said one had to be a natural born citizen to run for POTUS?
From a practical real life point of view that still remains unclear. .
Let the people decide. Vote.
Many people would love to turn the clock back to before Merkut was born …
She did not express any regret; she regretted that people did not grow up to her level, which is yet another insult to people’s intelligence.