A supply glut of used cars coupled with subprime lending finally came to the forefront with a Profit Warning From Ally Financial.

Ally Financial Inc. warned profit may grow less than anticipated only a few months ago, the latest sign that automakers’ heavy discounting and aggressive use of leasing to boost sales has created a supply glut hurting lenders and rental-car companies.

Earnings may increase as little as 5 percent this year, Ally said Tuesday, after Chief Executive Officer Jeffrey Brown in January predicted growth “shy of 15 percent but still very solid.” The caution raised by the Detroit-based company dragged on shares of rental companies and auto dealer groups including Hertz Global Holdings Inc. and AutoNation Inc.

Steeper Slide

While Ally had expected a 5 percent drop in used-car prices in the near term, the lender saw a 7 percent slide in the first quarter, which could cost $15 million to $20 million, Halmy said during a Tuesday conference call with analysts.

“Used-vehicle prices continue to decline at a manageable rate, but a bit higher than last year’s pace,” he said. “We do expect the used-car market to rebound more in the second quarter.”

“Auto we think is going to slow down because people will stress on credit,” Jamie Dimon, chief executive officer of JPMorgan Chase & Co., said at the company’s investor day on Feb. 28. “You’re going to see some issues there, but it’s not systemic.”

Used Cars Threatens Ford Profits

Also in the not systemic category, we note that a Rising Tide of Used Cars Threatens Ford’s Profits.

A glut of used vehicles has started to depress prices. That trend will intensify as Americans will return 3.36 million leased cars and trucks this year, another jump after a 33 percent surge in 2016, according to J.D. Power. The fallout has already begun, with Ford Motor Co. shaving $300 million from its financial-services arm’s profit forecast for this year.

“Ford is the canary in the coal mine,” said Maryann Keller, a former Wall Street analyst who’s now an auto industry consultant in Stamford, Connecticut.

Cheaper Payments

New vehicle sales have jumped each of the last seven years, the longest period since at least the days of the Model T. When used car values were strong, it enabled automakers to offer consumers cheaper lease payments.

Leasing has helped consumers afford new vehicles becoming more expensive than ever. Prices have climbed 13 percent to $34,067 over the past five years, according to Edmunds.com, a rise partially driven by booming popularity of pricier trucks and sport utility vehicles.

The question for auto companies is whether pulling those levers will offset any losses from overlooking the true cost of using hefty incentives and discounted leases to boost new-vehicle sales.

“That’s just the game they play,” Keller said. “It’s deferring the loss, but those losses are now coming home to roost.”

Lending Growth Falling Fast

The Wall Street Journal says “President Donald Trump’s erratic style could be to blame for the recent slowdown in lending growth.” The slowdown in Bank Lending Signals Caution.

Lending growth has recently been slowing in the U.S., a potentially ominous economic signal. Policy uncertainty under President Donald Trump may be partly to blame.

Total loans and leases by U.S. commercial banks are currently rising at an annual pace of about 5%, based on weekly seasonally adjusted data from the Federal Reserve. That is down from a 6.4% pace for all of last year and peak rates of around 8% in mid-2016.

The deceleration has been broad-based across business, real estate, and consumer lending and is at odds with the idea of a stronger economy and rising sentiment. The slowdown has been particularly stark in commercial and industrial lending, which was growing at around 10% in the first half of last year, but is now up just 5.7% from a year earlier.

Sentiment vs Uncertainty

Allegedly, lending may be down because of Trump uncertainty but it should be up because of sentiment. Previously, mainstream media touted the Trump economy and sentiment which is at a 17 year high.

Don’t worry! The lending slowdown is not systemic, it’s just a temporary artifact of the constant battle between sentiment and uncertainty.

Sentiment and uncertainty talk is all a bunch of total nonsense, repeated over and over. Economists actually believe in such snake oil.

Related Articles

  1. Used Car Prices Plunge Most in Any Month Since 2008, Only 2nd February Decline in 20 Years
  2. Consumer Sentiment Statistical Noise: Modern Day Snake Oil

Mike “Mish” Shedlock